• BristolPress | Story Of The Day
Wednesday, November 18, 2026
  • Login
Bristol Press
  • Home
  • World
  • News
  • Politics
    Young Scots will be left poorer if ‘pushed towards jobs that don’t exist’

    Young Scots will be left poorer if ‘pushed towards jobs that don’t exist’

    Scots invited to share their views on John Swinney plan to slash number of councils

    Scots invited to share their views on John Swinney plan to slash number of councils

    Scottish Labour is ready to talk with the SNP to deliver more support for households this winter

    Scottish Labour is ready to talk with the SNP to deliver more support for households this winter

    SNP £2 bus fare cap punches ‘significant hole’ in ScotRail budget as passengers ditch trains

    SNP £2 bus fare cap punches ‘significant hole’ in ScotRail budget as passengers ditch trains

    Most Scots doubt Nicola Sturgeon denials over Peter Murrell embezzlement

    Most Scots doubt Nicola Sturgeon denials over Peter Murrell embezzlement

    John Healey paves the way for early general election but long winter lies ahead for Labour

    John Healey paves the way for early general election but long winter lies ahead for Labour

    Jackdaw gas field to supply Scots homes within weeks as Andy Burnham pledges to ‘bring down bills’

    Jackdaw gas field to supply Scots homes within weeks as Andy Burnham pledges to ‘bring down bills’

    SNP slams ‘despicable’ benefits advice websites conning vulnerable Scots out of cash

    SNP slams ‘despicable’ benefits advice websites conning vulnerable Scots out of cash

    Andy Burnham says he wants to ‘move beyond constitutional questions’ on Scotland visit

    Andy Burnham says he wants to ‘move beyond constitutional questions’ on Scotland visit

    Andy Burnham says closer ties with EU would boost Scots businesses and grow UK economy

    Andy Burnham says closer ties with EU would boost Scots businesses and grow UK economy

    John Swinney plan to slash health boards and merge councils could cause ‘decade of distraction’

    John Swinney plan to slash health boards and merge councils could cause ‘decade of distraction’

    ‘Michael Marra is the best street fighter Scottish Labour has’

    ‘Michael Marra is the best street fighter Scottish Labour has’

  • Business

    Salesforce boss Marc Benioff joins Weev.

    What is a virtual office and why you need one in Central London – Your Company Formations Ltd

    What is a virtual office and why you need one in Central London – Your Company Formations Ltd

    Inflation rises again to new 40-year high

    Inflation rises again to new 40-year high

    Bank of England hikes interest rates to 1.25%

    Bank of England hikes interest rates to 1.25%

    Hiring activity in Scotland slows amid steep decline in staff availability

    Hiring activity in Scotland slows amid steep decline in staff availability

    Scottish retail footfall growth ‘worst in UK compared to pre-pandemic’

    Scottish retail footfall growth ‘worst in UK compared to pre-pandemic’

  • Sports
    Jadon Sancho’s message from Martin O’Neill as Celtic told staggering fees behind free agent deal

    Jadon Sancho’s message from Martin O’Neill as Celtic told staggering fees behind free agent deal

    Celtic see Gvidas Gineitis test unwritten transfer rule after irked agent ‘stung’ by Torino exit collapse

    Celtic see Gvidas Gineitis test unwritten transfer rule after irked agent ‘stung’ by Torino exit collapse

    Hearts injury relief just around the corner as Wouter Vrancken earmarks 6 stars for Jambos return

    Hearts injury relief just around the corner as Wouter Vrancken earmarks 6 stars for Jambos return

    Scotland to win international tug of war race as U21s swoop for ex St Mirren starlet

    Scotland to win international tug of war race as U21s swoop for ex St Mirren starlet

    Falkirk 2 Celtic 0 LIVE reaction as Martin O’Neill sees pressure crank up after shocker from the champions

    Falkirk 2 Celtic 0 LIVE reaction as Martin O’Neill sees pressure crank up after shocker from the champions

    Age old Celtic and Rangers debate rages as defection theory given brutal Hotline reality check

    Age old Celtic and Rangers debate rages as defection theory given brutal Hotline reality check

    Rangers vs St Johnstone LIVE! Latest updates from the huge Premiership showdown at Ibrox

    Rangers vs St Johnstone LIVE! Latest updates from the huge Premiership showdown at Ibrox

    Former Hearts scout and kitman John Harvey passes away as tributes paid to son of ex Tynecastle boss

    Former Hearts scout and kitman John Harvey passes away as tributes paid to son of ex Tynecastle boss

    Benjamin Nygren refuses to buy Celtic excuses as he can’t answer key question amid packed Parkhead schedule

    Benjamin Nygren refuses to buy Celtic excuses as he can’t answer key question amid packed Parkhead schedule

    Liam Scales insists Celtic have a point to prove against Benfica as shock Euro win is the benchmark

    Liam Scales insists Celtic have a point to prove against Benfica as shock Euro win is the benchmark

    Inside Sir Alex Ferguson’s trip to Rangers HQ as Derek McInnes uses priceless sounding board once again

    Inside Sir Alex Ferguson’s trip to Rangers HQ as Derek McInnes uses priceless sounding board once again

    Transfer news LIVE as Rangers and Celtic plus Hearts, Aberdeen and Hibs eye signings

    Transfer news LIVE as Rangers and Celtic plus Hearts, Aberdeen and Hibs eye signings

  • Technology
    GTA 6 launch deal sees PS5 edition drop below £49 as pre-load goes live

    GTA 6 launch deal sees PS5 edition drop below £49 as pre-load goes live

    Apple fans ‘hurry’ to bag first iPhone 18 Pro Black Friday deals

    Apple fans ‘hurry’ to bag first iPhone 18 Pro Black Friday deals

    Police Scotland issues ‘housebreaking’ alert as people urged to prepare for October 25

    Police Scotland issues ‘housebreaking’ alert as people urged to prepare for October 25

    Alert to Brits as Google Cloud outage affects Bank of Scotland, Royal Mail and HSBC

    Alert to Brits as Google Cloud outage affects Bank of Scotland, Royal Mail and HSBC

    FREE thriller eBooks with this weekend’s Daily Record and Sunday Mail newspapers

    FREE thriller eBooks with this weekend’s Daily Record and Sunday Mail newspapers

  • Health
    Where can you donate blood as NHS Scotland issues ‘first ever’ Amber Alert

    Where can you donate blood as NHS Scotland issues ‘first ever’ Amber Alert

    Scottish farmers urged to get free NHS flu jab to stop creation of ‘new virus’

    Scottish farmers urged to get free NHS flu jab to stop creation of ‘new virus’

    Subtle signs your beloved pet dog is in pain that can be ‘easy to miss’

    Subtle signs your beloved pet dog is in pain that can be ‘easy to miss’

    Vaccine to no longer be used after deaths and hospitalisations

    Vaccine to no longer be used after deaths and hospitalisations

    Dad’s dental appointment for numb mouth led to devastating terminal cancer diagnosis

    Dad’s dental appointment for numb mouth led to devastating terminal cancer diagnosis

  • Entertainment
    B&M’s £5 item to prevent heat loss as British Gas shares ‘get ready’ winter checklist

    B&M’s £5 item to prevent heat loss as British Gas shares ‘get ready’ winter checklist

    ‘I tried cooking steak in the air fryer and it’s better than using a frying pan for two reasons’

    ‘I tried cooking steak in the air fryer and it’s better than using a frying pan for two reasons’

    Food reviewer tries Greggs’ new Christmas menu and doesn’t recommend 1 item

    Food reviewer tries Greggs’ new Christmas menu and doesn’t recommend 1 item

    Full list of benefits and extra financial support for people with a disability

    Full list of benefits and extra financial support for people with a disability

    Stationery chain with more than 400 stores to close another Scots branch on this date

    Stationery chain with more than 400 stores to close another Scots branch on this date

  • Life Style
  • Travel
  • Education
    MSs send spiky letter after Wales’ education reforms questioned by people who helped shape them

    MSs send spiky letter after Wales’ education reforms questioned by people who helped shape them

    College lecturer caught cheating by giving students higher grades

    College lecturer caught cheating by giving students higher grades

    Andy Burnham to be told ‘possibly replace Universal Credit and PIP’ for 1 million claimants

    Andy Burnham to be told ‘possibly replace Universal Credit and PIP’ for 1 million claimants

    Welsh teacher’s inappropriate messages to teenager exposed in deluge of emails

    Welsh teacher’s inappropriate messages to teenager exposed in deluge of emails

    New DWP update over ‘toxic’ weedkiller used in school playgrounds, parks and farms

    New DWP update over ‘toxic’ weedkiller used in school playgrounds, parks and farms

  • Real Estate
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • World
  • News
  • Politics
    Young Scots will be left poorer if ‘pushed towards jobs that don’t exist’

    Young Scots will be left poorer if ‘pushed towards jobs that don’t exist’

    Scots invited to share their views on John Swinney plan to slash number of councils

    Scots invited to share their views on John Swinney plan to slash number of councils

    Scottish Labour is ready to talk with the SNP to deliver more support for households this winter

    Scottish Labour is ready to talk with the SNP to deliver more support for households this winter

    SNP £2 bus fare cap punches ‘significant hole’ in ScotRail budget as passengers ditch trains

    SNP £2 bus fare cap punches ‘significant hole’ in ScotRail budget as passengers ditch trains

    Most Scots doubt Nicola Sturgeon denials over Peter Murrell embezzlement

    Most Scots doubt Nicola Sturgeon denials over Peter Murrell embezzlement

    John Healey paves the way for early general election but long winter lies ahead for Labour

    John Healey paves the way for early general election but long winter lies ahead for Labour

    Jackdaw gas field to supply Scots homes within weeks as Andy Burnham pledges to ‘bring down bills’

    Jackdaw gas field to supply Scots homes within weeks as Andy Burnham pledges to ‘bring down bills’

    SNP slams ‘despicable’ benefits advice websites conning vulnerable Scots out of cash

    SNP slams ‘despicable’ benefits advice websites conning vulnerable Scots out of cash

    Andy Burnham says he wants to ‘move beyond constitutional questions’ on Scotland visit

    Andy Burnham says he wants to ‘move beyond constitutional questions’ on Scotland visit

    Andy Burnham says closer ties with EU would boost Scots businesses and grow UK economy

    Andy Burnham says closer ties with EU would boost Scots businesses and grow UK economy

    John Swinney plan to slash health boards and merge councils could cause ‘decade of distraction’

    John Swinney plan to slash health boards and merge councils could cause ‘decade of distraction’

    ‘Michael Marra is the best street fighter Scottish Labour has’

    ‘Michael Marra is the best street fighter Scottish Labour has’

  • Business

    Salesforce boss Marc Benioff joins Weev.

    What is a virtual office and why you need one in Central London – Your Company Formations Ltd

    What is a virtual office and why you need one in Central London – Your Company Formations Ltd

    Inflation rises again to new 40-year high

    Inflation rises again to new 40-year high

    Bank of England hikes interest rates to 1.25%

    Bank of England hikes interest rates to 1.25%

    Hiring activity in Scotland slows amid steep decline in staff availability

    Hiring activity in Scotland slows amid steep decline in staff availability

    Scottish retail footfall growth ‘worst in UK compared to pre-pandemic’

    Scottish retail footfall growth ‘worst in UK compared to pre-pandemic’

  • Sports
    Jadon Sancho’s message from Martin O’Neill as Celtic told staggering fees behind free agent deal

    Jadon Sancho’s message from Martin O’Neill as Celtic told staggering fees behind free agent deal

    Celtic see Gvidas Gineitis test unwritten transfer rule after irked agent ‘stung’ by Torino exit collapse

    Celtic see Gvidas Gineitis test unwritten transfer rule after irked agent ‘stung’ by Torino exit collapse

    Hearts injury relief just around the corner as Wouter Vrancken earmarks 6 stars for Jambos return

    Hearts injury relief just around the corner as Wouter Vrancken earmarks 6 stars for Jambos return

    Scotland to win international tug of war race as U21s swoop for ex St Mirren starlet

    Scotland to win international tug of war race as U21s swoop for ex St Mirren starlet

    Falkirk 2 Celtic 0 LIVE reaction as Martin O’Neill sees pressure crank up after shocker from the champions

    Falkirk 2 Celtic 0 LIVE reaction as Martin O’Neill sees pressure crank up after shocker from the champions

    Age old Celtic and Rangers debate rages as defection theory given brutal Hotline reality check

    Age old Celtic and Rangers debate rages as defection theory given brutal Hotline reality check

    Rangers vs St Johnstone LIVE! Latest updates from the huge Premiership showdown at Ibrox

    Rangers vs St Johnstone LIVE! Latest updates from the huge Premiership showdown at Ibrox

    Former Hearts scout and kitman John Harvey passes away as tributes paid to son of ex Tynecastle boss

    Former Hearts scout and kitman John Harvey passes away as tributes paid to son of ex Tynecastle boss

    Benjamin Nygren refuses to buy Celtic excuses as he can’t answer key question amid packed Parkhead schedule

    Benjamin Nygren refuses to buy Celtic excuses as he can’t answer key question amid packed Parkhead schedule

    Liam Scales insists Celtic have a point to prove against Benfica as shock Euro win is the benchmark

    Liam Scales insists Celtic have a point to prove against Benfica as shock Euro win is the benchmark

    Inside Sir Alex Ferguson’s trip to Rangers HQ as Derek McInnes uses priceless sounding board once again

    Inside Sir Alex Ferguson’s trip to Rangers HQ as Derek McInnes uses priceless sounding board once again

    Transfer news LIVE as Rangers and Celtic plus Hearts, Aberdeen and Hibs eye signings

    Transfer news LIVE as Rangers and Celtic plus Hearts, Aberdeen and Hibs eye signings

  • Technology
    GTA 6 launch deal sees PS5 edition drop below £49 as pre-load goes live

    GTA 6 launch deal sees PS5 edition drop below £49 as pre-load goes live

    Apple fans ‘hurry’ to bag first iPhone 18 Pro Black Friday deals

    Apple fans ‘hurry’ to bag first iPhone 18 Pro Black Friday deals

    Police Scotland issues ‘housebreaking’ alert as people urged to prepare for October 25

    Police Scotland issues ‘housebreaking’ alert as people urged to prepare for October 25

    Alert to Brits as Google Cloud outage affects Bank of Scotland, Royal Mail and HSBC

    Alert to Brits as Google Cloud outage affects Bank of Scotland, Royal Mail and HSBC

    FREE thriller eBooks with this weekend’s Daily Record and Sunday Mail newspapers

    FREE thriller eBooks with this weekend’s Daily Record and Sunday Mail newspapers

  • Health
    Where can you donate blood as NHS Scotland issues ‘first ever’ Amber Alert

    Where can you donate blood as NHS Scotland issues ‘first ever’ Amber Alert

    Scottish farmers urged to get free NHS flu jab to stop creation of ‘new virus’

    Scottish farmers urged to get free NHS flu jab to stop creation of ‘new virus’

    Subtle signs your beloved pet dog is in pain that can be ‘easy to miss’

    Subtle signs your beloved pet dog is in pain that can be ‘easy to miss’

    Vaccine to no longer be used after deaths and hospitalisations

    Vaccine to no longer be used after deaths and hospitalisations

    Dad’s dental appointment for numb mouth led to devastating terminal cancer diagnosis

    Dad’s dental appointment for numb mouth led to devastating terminal cancer diagnosis

  • Entertainment
    B&M’s £5 item to prevent heat loss as British Gas shares ‘get ready’ winter checklist

    B&M’s £5 item to prevent heat loss as British Gas shares ‘get ready’ winter checklist

    ‘I tried cooking steak in the air fryer and it’s better than using a frying pan for two reasons’

    ‘I tried cooking steak in the air fryer and it’s better than using a frying pan for two reasons’

    Food reviewer tries Greggs’ new Christmas menu and doesn’t recommend 1 item

    Food reviewer tries Greggs’ new Christmas menu and doesn’t recommend 1 item

    Full list of benefits and extra financial support for people with a disability

    Full list of benefits and extra financial support for people with a disability

    Stationery chain with more than 400 stores to close another Scots branch on this date

    Stationery chain with more than 400 stores to close another Scots branch on this date

  • Life Style
  • Travel
  • Education
    MSs send spiky letter after Wales’ education reforms questioned by people who helped shape them

    MSs send spiky letter after Wales’ education reforms questioned by people who helped shape them

    College lecturer caught cheating by giving students higher grades

    College lecturer caught cheating by giving students higher grades

    Andy Burnham to be told ‘possibly replace Universal Credit and PIP’ for 1 million claimants

    Andy Burnham to be told ‘possibly replace Universal Credit and PIP’ for 1 million claimants

    Welsh teacher’s inappropriate messages to teenager exposed in deluge of emails

    Welsh teacher’s inappropriate messages to teenager exposed in deluge of emails

    New DWP update over ‘toxic’ weedkiller used in school playgrounds, parks and farms

    New DWP update over ‘toxic’ weedkiller used in school playgrounds, parks and farms

  • Real Estate
No Result
View All Result
Bristol Press
No Result
View All Result

Just Stop Oil’s harsh sentences are the logical outcome of Britain’s authoritarian turn against protest

by BP Author
July 21, 2024
in World
0
0
SHARES
24
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter


Lengthy prison sentences have been imposed on five Just Stop Oil activists for coordinating direct action on the M25, the main ring road around London. For a non-violent protest, there is no equivalent in modern times.

The five years for Roger Hallam and four years for the remaining four: Daniel Shaw, Louise Lancaster, Cressida Gethin and Lucia Whittaker de Abreu, have been widely condemned as grossly disproportionate. According to one snap poll, 61% of the public consider the sentences too harsh.

But nobody should be surprised: these sentences are a logical outcome of Britain’s authoritarian turn against protest over the past five years.

Protest in England and Wales was previously dealt with by the courts according to what we call Hoffmann’s Bargain. This meant protesters should accept their guilt in court, but their conscientiousness – along with the wider importance of disruptive protest to democracy – would be rewarded with lenient sentences.

This changed with the prosecution of the Stansted 15, who were charged and found guilty of terrorist-related offences for stopping a deportation flight in 2017. The 15 were sentenced to community service, fines, and for some, short suspended prison sentences. On appeal, the Court of Appeal threw out the charges in 2021, but at the same time hardened the general approach of the courts to protest, confirming that a key defence (known as necessity) was not available to protest defendants in court.




Read more:
The Stansted 15 appeal: a hollow victory for the right to protest?


Making it harder for activists to defend themselves

Since then, three things have happened. First, other potential defences that protesters could rely on, including lawful excuse, have been systematically restricted by the Court of Appeal.

Second, the Crown Prosecution Service (CPS) has sought where possible to bring more serious charges against protesters than used to be the case. In this they have been encouraged by new legislation brought in by the last government, notably the Police, Crime, Sentencing and Courts Act (2022) and the Public Order Act (2023).

Third, judges have typically sought to control and reduce the time that defendants have in court to explain their motives to the jury, because – without a defence in law – the defendants’ arguments are, in legal terms, not relevant.

Traffic motorway

Just Stop Oil activists disrupt the M25 in November 2022, the action which saw five activists jailed.
Mark Kerrison / Alamy

We saw each of these dynamics in the Just Stop Oil “Conspiracy 5” trial. Before 2018, public nuisance itself was barely used for protest offences, but the CPS now regularly brings this charge against peaceful protesters. But the charge of a conspiracy to cause public nuisance, which these five defendants faced, is a further escalation as it treats protest movements as a criminal enterprise, and does not allow a lawful excuse defence. As a consequence, the stakes are higher and the outcomes more serious.

In court, the defendants were unable to argue that they had a lawful excuse for their action (Hallam repeatedly tried to argue this in court, and was repeatedly shut down by the trial judge). Finally, although the defendants did manage to explain their motives to the jury, the jury had no opportunity to find them not guilty in law. Although juries still have the power to find defendants not guilty by making a moral rather than a legal decision, this is much harder and rarer.

The result is that the first part of Hoffmann’s Bargain is being abandoned. With no recourse to a defence in law, protest defendants are now regularly being found guilty. But the second part of the bargain, leniency at sentencing, is increasingly being forgotten.

A new benchmark

In April 2023, Just Stop Oil activists Morgan Trowland and Marcus Decker were sentenced to three years and two years seven months in prison respectively after being convicted of public nuisance for disrupting the Dartford Crossing, a large bridge over the Thames to the east of London. Upheld by the Court of Appeal, these sentences have now become a benchmark.

In the Conspiracy 5 case, the trial judge explicitly cited this benchmark as the basis for the sentences he imposed, and any appeal against them will have to reckon with the Court of Appeal’s determination that they are fair.

This case brings into sharp focus two very contrasting visions of what a trial is, and what the criminal law is for. The courts are effectively treating protest trials as a legal flowchart, with a strict distinction between what is and what is not relevant on the shortest route to a verdict.

But defendants often see the courts as a place where they can make urgent arguments about moral values and social justice. Rather than a public nuisance, they consider their actions a public service. By not allowing defendants to account for their actions properly, the courts create an artificial separation between law and politics, and diminish the democratic agency of juries.

By imposing prison sentences on non-violent protesters, they impose authoritarian responses to pressing social problems.



Source link

Previous Post

Shiba Inu Ecosystem Soars, Whale Activity in the Spotlight — Blockchain Media Indonesia

Next Post

Shiba Inu Potential to Rise to US$0.000045 — Blockchain Media Indonesia

Next Post
Shiba Inu Potential to Rise to US$0.000045 — Blockchain Media Indonesia

Shiba Inu Potential to Rise to US$0.000045 — Blockchain Media Indonesia

  • BristolPress | Story Of The Day
  • Privacy Policy
  • Publishing Request
  • Contact

Copyrights © 2024 BristoPress.co.uk | One of the authentic and fast UK News source.

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In
No Result
View All Result
  • BristolPress | Story Of The Day
  • Contact
  • Privacy Policy

Copyrights © 2024 BristoPress.co.uk | One of the authentic and fast UK News source.